This page is for discussing the contents of Hockey Stick Controversy.
When the page gets built up and the criticisms of each proxy are posted, I think it'd be a good idea to say which multiproxy reconstructions contain these problems/proxies. If you agree that that's a good idea, would you prefer to see it on this page (i.e. list studies on tree ring page that use bristlecones, list studies with various bad statistical methods, etc) or mentioned on each paper's page at Multiproxy_Temperature_Reconstructions?

